Is Adam Lambert a future star or a boring wannabe?

Interesting pair of MSNBC articles debate the future career of Adam Lambert. In my opinion, Adam will be a huge star for years to come. The guy has mad talent and likability.....

MSNBC:
Adam Lambert is the guy who everyone wants to see, because he is willing to take risks and able to make them pay off. Every week, he walks that high-wire, and every week he emerges as the star of the night.

MSNBC:
Adam Lambert will probably win "American Idol," will probably get a ton of attention, and then will probably not become a huge star. There is a reason why melodramatic cast albums do not generally top the charts.